Tuesday, December 23, 2014

Top Brony Musicians of 2014

It is that time again. Time to reflect on who the most popular musicians in the fandom are; time for the list of the Top Brony Musicians of 2014. We have updated the list for  a new year.  As always many people have dropped out, moved on, moved up, and many new people have joined the list of 1k+ youtube subs.

If you see anyone over 1,000 subs who we have missed (which is very possible) let us know in comments and we'll add them to the list when we get a chance.

Fritzybeat has included musicians with fully deleted channels in the list, based on the sub count they reached before deleting their account. "Inactive" he has put beside ANY musician, whether their channel is still up or not, who no longer makes pony music, or at least, hasn't made ANY pony music in over a year.

The Honorable Mentions are also a bit different, as that list includes musicians who have made music in the fandom before, but aren't considered "Brony Musicians" (AKA DJ Amaya, Ken Ashcorp, etc...), or musicians who are engaged in the fandom, but don't necessarily make pony music (AKA Michelle Creber, Hey Ocean!, etc...). Also an ** by anyone who does far more than music. If we're missing anyone, as always let us know and we'll update and add them!

Remember that popularity is not the same thing as quality and that there is no reason for being butthurt over the brony community's favorites. We will update this list again likely next year or on the half anniversary.

(Re-Updated on Dec 23, 2014)<-------------->See this list for Active and Inactive Lists


1 536,048
The Living Tombstone **
2 200,819
WoodenToaster/Glaze  
3 98,178
SimGretina

4 97,514
Alex S  (Inactive)
5 90,554
MandoPony 
6 85,507
Black Gryph0n **
7 82,557
Mic the Microphone **
8 81,131
PON3/Vinyl Scratch
9 64,491
Aviators
10 50,623
EileMonty **
11 49,788
JackTHerbert **
12 49,005
Sherclop Pones **
13 46,885
Archie
14 45,299
Omnipony (Inactive)
15 41,745
Eurobeat Brony
16 41,085
AcousticBrony
17 35,836
Assertive Fluttershy (Inactive)
18 35,239
PinkiePieSwear (Inactive)
19 34,583
Sayonara Maxwell **
20 34,084
Jackle App (Inactive)
21 32,931
PrinceWhateverer
22 32,657
RainbowCrash88 (Inactive)
23 32,072
Forest Rain
24 31,911
Aftermath/Fire of Friendship
25 29,654
WaveformThePegasus**
26 28,843
AcoustiMandoBrony
27 28,661
Nowacking **
28 28,612
ShadyVox (Inactive)
29 28,475
General Mumble
30 28,363
Rina-chan **
31 28,153
Ponyphonic
32 28,087
Twitch
33 24,962
Foozogz
34 24,054
Silva Hound
35 23,434
Bronyfied (Inactive)
36 22,915
MEMJ **
37 22,737
OhPonyBoy **
38 21,530
TuXe (Inactive)
39 21,165
Delta Brony
40 21,063
dBPony
41 19,789
Evening Star
42 18,274
Notion **
43 17,353
Feather
44 17,313
H8_Seed (Inactive)
45 17,307
Dustykatt **
46 17,297
Pixeltripper **
47 17,122
SlyphStorm 
48 16,723
TAPS
49 16,324
Ibringdalulz ** (Inactive)
50 16,317
AwkwardMarina
51 16,049
All Levels at Once (Inactive)
52 15,928
PsychGoth/Bagpipe Brony
53 15,253
d.notive
54 13,955
Coconeru **
55 13,936
Makkon (Inactive)
56 13,860
puccagarukiss**
57 12,905
Carbon Maestro
58 12,657
YourEnigma
59 11,802
Carmen ~ Mary Medley** 
60 11,799
4EverfreeBrony 
61 11,441
Replacer
62 11,351
Joaftheloaf
63 11,339
TwentyTen (Inactive)
64 11,235
InfinityDash **
65 11,185
Tsyolin (Inactive)
66 10,951
Yelling at Cats (Inactive)
67 10,600
ArtAttack (Inactive)
68 10,222
SoGreatandPowerful (Inactive)
69 10,186
PurpleRoselyn
70 9,674
ElectroKaplosion
71 9,555
TeiThePony (Inactive)
72 9,545
JoshLohMusic (Inactive)
73 9,534
Stormwolf (Inactive)
74 9,387
Not A Clever Pony (Inactive)
75 8,815
FlutterRex (Inactive)
76 8,521
Poni1Kenobi
77 8,434
Kenny9807 **
78 8,374
Dreamchan **
79 8,322
MHM (Inactive)
80 8,116
The L-Train
81 7,994
Dj Gestap
82 7,897
Claire Anne Carr
83 7,719
Interrobang Pie (Inactive)
84 7,641
Navy Brony **
85 7,476
TIFWhitney
86 7,407
GatoPaint
87 7,065
Baasik
88 6,996
David Larsen
89 6,715
JayB
90 6,584
ThatSonofaMitch
91 6,577
magpiepony**
92 6,406
TheDashDub (Inactive)
93 6,324
Kathy-chan
94 6,232
Varia (Inactive)
95 6,081
Radiarc
96 6,006
OrchestralDesign
97 5,995
MelodicPony
98 5,887
Megaphoric
99 5,695
Wasteland Wailers **
100 5,582
Dr.Dissonance (Inactive)
101 5,520
PhillyPu (Inactive)
102 5,393
TripleBlueShell (Inactive)
103 5,326
PhonyBrony (Inactive)
104 5,324
µThunder
105 5,305
SMOR3S
106 5,097
TheSaltlakrits (Inactive)
107 5,033
GaugeN
108 5,029
Matthew Mosier (Inactive)
109 4,881
NomNom (Inactive)
110 4,862
Stars In Autumn/Jeffthestrider (Inactive)
111 4,842
Lavender Harmony
112 4,820
Jeff Burgess/Rarity/Julian Moon
113 4,810
Chaos Sprite/Error 503
114 4,788
Hirosashii
115 4,770
F3nning
116 4,765
The Beatle Bronies (Inactive)
117 4,759
BronyMike
118 4,749
&I (Andi)
119 4,723
Chain Algorithm (Inactive)
120 4,707
Cyril the Wolf
121 4,674
Tarby
122 4,591
Stablefree
123 4,477
Flaedr
124 4,440
Derpidety
125 4,428
Jupiter Maroon
126 4,394
Nicolas Dominique
127 4,388
Toastwaffle
128 4,383
Keep On Rockin' Brony / Icky (Inactive)
129 4,321
Muse of Discord
130 4,320
Neighsayer
131 4,296
ilysabeth (Inactive)
132 4,290
Emily Koch/PKEmi
133 4,210
itsannachloem**
134 4,194
Music By Octavia (Inactive)
135 4,190
MysteriousBronie
136 4,186
oodorato2
137 4,174
Korw (Inactive)
138 4,166
Pony! (Vylet Pony)
139 4,154
Baschfire (Inactive)
140 4,137
Whitetail (Inactive)
141 4,059
Sonic Breakbeat (Inactive)
142 4,054
Koroshi-Ya (Inactive)
143 4,047
174UDSI
144 3,953
Elliptisoar (Inactive)
145 3,937
Lenich (Inactive)
146 3,930
Chi-chi
147 3,883
Gunca **
148 3,867
DongleKumquat
149 3,849
VocalScorePony
150 3,849
Lectro Dub
151 3,848
Echelon (Inactive)
152 3,804
JoinedTheHerd/Sub.Sound
153 3,790
PonyFireStone
154 3,750
LilyCloud
155 3,732
Emily Jones/FlutterTreeMuffin
156 3,697
Woody
157 3,695
daks (Inactive)
158 3,616
ismBoF (Inactive)
159 3,611
Sand Josieph
160 3,559
Trance Blossom (Inactive)
161 3,537
Pipsqueak/:rustage/TheDumplingz
162 3,524
Zahqo & Haymaker
163 3,479
Yoka the Changeling (Inactive)
164 3,472
Ibeabronyrapper/IbeConCept
165 3,406
Synthis
166 3,306
wacarb 
167 3,281
Aoshi
168 3,166
Wind Wolf/Night Breeze
169 3,039
Griffinilla **
170 3,008
Alioopster27** (Inactive)
171 3,008
Skybolt
172 3,004
UndreamedPanic
173 2,958
Addictia (Inactive)
174 2,954
AgileDash (Inactive)
175 2,949
Canapplejack
176 2,944
Decibelle
177 2,898
Metal Core Pony
178 2,889
UnderpΩny
179 2,877
Slendermane
180 2,818
Turquoise Splash
181 2,773
Knife Pony
182 2,750
Wolf of Sadness (Inactive)
183 2,724
Catfood Mcfly (Inactive)
184 2,703
CommandSpry (Inactive)
185 2,679
BassBeastJD
186 2,656
Steven, A.D.
187 2,652
Muffoxx
188 2,647
PonyVisation (Inactive)
189 2,561
Cats Miillionaire (Inactive)
190 2,544
Rev897 ** (Inactive)
191 2,533
Chief Doggingfood
192 2,528
CxDr/Cherax Destructor
193 2,528
Pinkie Guy (Inactive)
194 2,459
Meredith Sims
195 2,420
Jcarlson04 (Inactive)
196 2,403
Mush
197 2,398
MetaJoker
198 2,360
VoodooPony
199 2,350
stringstorm**
200 2,299
DaWillstanator
201 2,273
Blaze
202 2,228
And The Rainfall
203 2,205
SerenaMidori **
204 2,186
Thorinair
205 2,163
ColaEuphoria (Inactive)
206 2,156
Nameless Warning (Inactive)
207 2,120
Vivace Capriccioso/Winter's Muse
208 2,114
M Pallante/Brony FX
209 2,113
FritzyBeat
210 2,106
MIU
211 2,104
Neu KatalYst (Inactive)
212 2,058
Undefined Variable **
213 2,042
Michael A (Inactive)
214 2,030
Rhyme Flow
215 2,023
NRGFORCE (Inactive)
216 2,020
Risen/RisenFromTheDust
217 1,997
Seventh Element
218 1,978
Freewave
219 1,945
Pinkie Cake (Inactive)
220 1,914
Speedcore Dave
221 1,905
Psychedelic Brony (Inactive)
222 1,899
Automatic Jack
223 1,877
Aspect of the Storm (Inactive)
224 1,875
Six of Lasers (Inactive)
225 1,860
Kyoga
226 1,836
Screams From Equestria
227 1,835
Artem Yegorov
228 1,825
Dethonator (Inactive)
229 1,796
Resonant Waves
230 1,772
Reverbrony
231 1,768
Eccentrifuge
232 1,752
Brony MACH **
233 1,739
Circuitfry ** (Inactive)
234 1,738
Mogul Dash
235 1,730
Mystery
236 1,705
Liquid Cobalt (Inactive)
237 1,692
Swagberg/Kabuto The Python (Inactive)
238 1,684
Facexplodie
239 1,660
Melodosis 
240 1,646
DerpyCrash
241 1,620
Giggly Maria
242 1,580
Ozzwald (Inactive)
243 1,566
SenatorMyth (Inactive)
244 1,563
Zatslol
245 1,554
Avenir/Glitchhog (Inactive)
246 1,549
Faux Synder
247 1,501
Scarlett Peace (Inactive)
248 1,496
FraGmenTd
249 1,496
Starborne
250 1,477
Thomas H./The ShadowRusher (Inactive)
251 1,469
sci
252 1,465
Evdog
253 1,460
Zehnny
254 1,456
PegaSix (Inactive)
255 1,450
MBAlpha (Inactive)
256 1,443
Nexgen
257 1,442
0neTr1ckP0ny
258 1,436
Le Soldat Pony
259 1,430
JoshSaysStuff (Inactive)
260 1,418
Starlight (Proctra & PegasYs)
261 1,401
Electro-BLITZ
262 1,391
SoaringFlight (Inactive)
263 1,380
REDD
264 1,378
Steven Knapp** (Inactive)
265 1,378
Jenny Nicholson
266 1,348
Warbalist
267 1,329
Patrick Poe
268 1,326
Exploding Heart Technique (EHT) (Inactive)
269 1,324
Royalpony
270 1,308
Phileo (Inactive)
271 1,306
HMage (Inactive)
272 1,306
Wisp X (Inactive)
273 1,293
PengWinBrony  (Inactive)
274 1,244
StrachAttack
275 1,228
The Opera Pony (Inactive)
276 1,220
Abrante (Inactive)
277 1,210
SquareHead
278 1,203
Arvianth
279 1,195
Captain Fluffaton (Inactive)
280 1,188
Mica
281 1,186
JoltMc
282 1,167
DasDeer
283 1,166
eXtaticus (Inactive)
284 1,160
Pencil Eraser
285 1,150
Jennabun
286 1,148
ESPPony (Inactive)
287 1,140
Skorp (Inactive)
288 1,139
Vinyl.rawr
289 1,124
Jastrian
290 1,113
EmberDash
291 1,112
MusicalPony/Colour District (Inactive)
292 1,088
Hackamore
293 1,087
Pony Music
294 1,068
Nexaka
295 1,065
Buffalo Brony/Arc of Albatross
296 1,057
Peak Freak (Inactive)
297 1,053
danielkon
298 1,033
RestrainedMadness (Inactive)
299 1,016
Hashbro ** (Inactive)
300 1,013
DJPoniver
301 1,012
Flight Rush
302 1,012
Markarian
303 1,010
Celtik (Inactive)
304 1,006
Sprocket
305 1,004
Temporal Walker
306 1,003
EquestrianLord (Inactive)
307 1,002
JakeLion **
308 1,001
Midnight Rain

1,000
EfimBrony





HONOURABLE MENTIONS:


???
DJ Amaya & Groovebot (Inactive)
215,458
AnimatedJames **
135,107
FiMFlamFilosophy **
123,987
Ken Ashcorp (Inactive)
72,270
Random Encounters
69,621
Ferexes **
53,378
Pierce Smoulder/BaldDumboRat **
37,131
Renard/Lapfox Trax (Inactive)
31,144
AlliKatNya (Inactive)
29,521
WaveformThePegasus **
19,342
Michelle Creber **
17,883
missbunniswan **
11,807
Pop Filter **
9,102
Hey Ocean!
7,481
NDLMongoose
4,030
Elspongie/Laszlo (Inactive)

We have to thank Fritzybeat for pouring over the sub counts of the previous list and for adding many new musicians who are brand new to the list. Also to Freewave for maintaining the yearly BMD list and running FIMM. With nearly 300 brony musicians with over 1k youtube subs there are even more musicians to get to know. See this list for Active and Inactive 2014 Lists. Here's the list from the end of 2013. Here's the prior list from 18 months ago. How times have changed!

78 comments:

  1. Well the comments and tumblr comments of who i missed keep coming in. I'm editing as quick as i can. Bear with me!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Could you please ffs stop encouraging more popularity contest bullshit?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree completely. It's not about the numbers, it's about the musicianship.

      Delete
    2. This is statistical, how are you going to rate everyone coming from different genres, musical experiences, ect? Subscribers provide a source for amount of fans and therefore the caliber of musical quality. Yeah there might be some unknown guys that are better than people on the list but how can you measure talent without being baised?

      Delete
    3. there isn't a way to do that, that's why this list is so fucking retarded.
      Take a look at how it's structured and presented. It literally implies that those with more subscribers are better, but if you take a look at the avergae narrow minded brony, you'll notice that most of them are attracted to generic, mediocre music, propably because it gets farted out by some musicians everyday because they don't give a single fuck about putting some effort into music and improving the production quality (prime example: Tombstone's babs seed remix).

      Delete
    4. Honestly there's no reason to get butthurt by such a list. NO ONE IS SAYING that anyone is better than any other, its just putting a list together based on the only unbiased criteria that anyone can show (ytube subs). If anything it should remind people to sub people you DO like and who make the effort. There's a lot of people who work hard for their music who couldn't make the list because people don't subscribe enough. That simple. No need to start drama or arguments. These are just stats.

      Delete
    5. Call me butthurt all you want, it still doesn't change the fact that you failed miserably at supporting your self-claimed goal with this list.
      Also there are unbiased criteria like production quality or arrangement.
      calling youtube subs unbiased is a joke

      Delete
    6. Okay how would you do it then lol

      Delete
    7. I didn't fail at all. I displayed where the community stacks up its artists based on the way that most people seem to measure it (popularity). I'm not to blame for why the community seems to put some above others. The fact that Tomb is #1 and SGAP is #26 speaks volumes to me but i'm not going to rig the results. The community voted with their subscription buttons.

      Delete
    8. I dono't see why people are making a big deal about this. its just a list.

      Delete
    9. I don't get it either. We didn't make any claims about musicianship in making this list. All we did was give an overview of the best known ones. Getting angry at statistics isn't going to do anything.

      Delete
    10. Why not just call it what it is: A list of the most subbed brony musicians on youtube? "Top Brony Musicians" definitely suggests "best."

      Delete
    11. Not in my opinion. In this context, all it means is "most influential/important ones". Which is definitely based on sub/follower count.

      Delete
    12. I for one agree with LoreRD.

      Delete
    13. Not necessarily. Popularity does not always relate with influence. For example, take the Velvet Underground, one of the if not the most influential Rock group of all time. They were never all too that popular, but as the quote goes "Velvet Underground only sold a few thousand albums, but everyone who bought one started a band. "

      Delete
    14. At this point.... popularity has changed to almost always relate to influence, or at least short-term influence. Since the brony fandom is recent, all we can measure is short term influence, which is what I intended in the initial post (in this context...), unlike your example of The Velvet Underground, whose influence became noticed only after quite a while. And the internet didn't exist back then. If it did, I'd guess they would've been more popular.

      Nowadays, almost always, things become influential and popular through sharing on the internet. If something's influential, especially in the short-term, people know about it.

      Since we're talking about the brony fandom, let me ask you this: do you think that anyone under 1,000 subscribers (if that) has any actual influence on this music community as a whole? (once again, think about context)

      Delete
    15. Well I know until recently there was some people who were very influential on the community like Sci who weren't above 1000 subscribers, but they are now. Anyway, while popularity generally corresponds with influence I don't think the order perfectly matches, for example I believe NotACleverPony is more influential than her subscriber count suggests, and while Tombstone is the most popular by far he isn't nearly as influential as his popularity suggests, with Glaze and Alex S definitely being more influential. Also, if you want to talk about influence and popularity they are have never quite been intertwined as much as you suggest even now. Pop artists are very popular, but they have little influence due to a lack of innovation. Meanwhile the most influential artists tend to be very popular within a certain domain and often the most popular artists in their respective genres, but aren't the most absolutely popular musicians overall.

      Delete
    16. There aren't enough musicians to "objectively" decide if e.g. Tomb is more influential tan Glaze or Alex S. And NotACleverPony had an incredibly high subscriber count for a very long time. She hasn't made any music in over a year and still is in the top 40. That should speak for itself. Also, I've been in musician's chatrooms where a lot of the more recent musicians have no idea who NaCP is. So I think it still stands.

      Delete
  3. I can't believe Tarby is so low in the standings. He is one of the best brony musicians in the world yet not enough people are aware of him it seems. Many of the top musicians site him as a rock god that they want to collab with too. I suggest everyone check him out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good point, he is the chosen one!! All hail the Tarby Jesus!!

      Delete
    2. Agreed. Tarby is best pony. Either most brines have no taste in music (possible by the blandness of some of the explanations I see coming out of them and the apparent restrictiveness of musical taste) or EQD is creating some sort of conspiracing to keep certain artists popular.

      Delete
    3. There is no such thing as "the best brony musician". All subjective.

      Delete
    4. Agreed. But it's still worth keeping track of this sort of thing.

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I can't believe Ponyphonic is on that low... Also where's BronyMike he has got 4,058 subs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ponyphonic has 3 videos and 7,200 subs. that's kind of ridiculous that they are that high but props to them regardless. I would put bronymike up there with yaplap as more a brony celebrity than musician tbh.

      Delete
  6. Are you planning on putting musicians that have under 1000 subs or would that be too much?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh look. We're in high school kiddies. Popularity clearly means a person is "better" now, huh? (And don't try to say it's based entirely on statistics, if it was get rid of the labels that say the most popular people are the essential gods of the community.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Holy shit stop over-analyzing this! It's not that big of a deal! And I mean how the hell would you rate a whole community of artists with different styles/genres then without being biased? You can't! Personally I find these stats informative and it's interesting to see who ranks where as far as subscribers go. But seriously stop living in a fantasy world were unknown people magically float up to the top of the list. Popularity IS everything (aka the real world) These folks have a bunch of subs for a reason, if they threw out shitty music they wouldn't have any fans.

      Delete
  8. You're missing eXtaticus, too.

    He makes some fantastic eurobeat; some would say that he's as good as (if not better than) the likes of Eurobeat Brony and Stormwolf.

    Wait...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. he's got 221 subs, he's got a way to go (like a lot of us) before he hits 1,000+. sorry.

      Delete
  9. Hoping to solve some questions and answer the disappointment of some people (which is understandable):

    Yes we did base our "top" list on the amount of subscriber they have on youtube, and yes we do know that it's not a legitimately good way of basing a list on.
    But it's the best we could do, obviously if we did a list with our own preferences or had a voting people would be like "Alex S is only in top of the votes because he posted on his youtube to go vote for him!!!!111!!!1111!!!11" or "Wow did you really put SoGreatAndPowerful in #1? you're so retarded, she isn't even close to the level of tombstone, glaze etc".

    Thing like these limits us to pure statistics, and there hasn't been any Brony musicians world cup (because it would be extremely hard to get a fair contest) yet so we couldn't base anything upon stuff like that.


    We had to do it with youtube subs and we know it's not the best approach, some of you might say a voting might've been better but keep in mind:
    1. Our following isn't that huge.
    2. If our following was really big and this list actually mattered it might have caused an even bigger popularity contest with people posting to their fans to come vote etc.
    3. We're all lazy (except for freewave) =]

    If you have something you want to say in terms of feedback and how we would go on about doing this next time, please post in the comments below, we take feedback seriously and we're always looking to improve!

    Much love -LFP

    ReplyDelete
  10. -Blue Thunder

    This is just a suggestion. Don't take anything i say as being offensive. I was reading these comments and i agree, this is the crapiest way to make a list of brony musicians (All though it is the only unbiased way... so far) I think i may have come up with a slightly time consuming way to remake the list (Slightly time consuming but i believe it will be more effective then the previous way). You send a mass message to all brony muscians to select one song that they have made. They send you their one song, and you place all of the songs on one page. Then you have people come on and listen to the songs one at a time. At the end of each song they will mark the song on a scale of 1 to 10 on how well it was made and weither they liked it. After a set number of days you count up the votes and declare the winner and list them all. (Obviously you will have to make it so only people regestered can vote only once so to stop someone from voting multiple times on a song, but i believe this will eleminate most of the biasness from the list. You could place the least known musicans at the top of the voting list so they get more exposure)This is just my opinion and it is a very Time Consuming process bu it is the only way i can think of for holding a near un-biased vote.

    -Blue Thunder

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Assuming everyone sent a song in, that would be a MASSIVE amount of music to go through and listen to. Too much to make an accurate poll out of. Even if we could somehow pull that off, they would essentially be voting for the song, not the artist.

      As it is, it's an organized list of musicians ordered by popularity based on an easily-measurable factor - Youtube subscriptions - and nothing more. In no way are we trying to say "this guy is better than this guy". Interesting idea, and we appreciate you trying to help us improve on the list, but not something we're up for at the moment.

      Delete
    2. What zero said, + the fact that it's insanely hard to get out a reply from any of the bigger musicians because they already get so many messages :\

      Delete
    3. like it said it would be time consuming and the only way I can see of making an accurate vote. However in this form it is an impossable task.

      Delete
    4. No. This would not work in any way (see what Zero said). A lot of musicians have much more variety in styles and genres than just one song. Look at Kyoga. Does he choose to submit his dark ambient stuff, or his guitar instrumentals? Or Peak Freak? He could choose to submit one of his rock tracks, but he can't make that stuff anymore, so it's not an accurate picture of what he can do.

      And more popular artists will STILL get higher marks, because more people will be familiar with their work and vote according to their discography, and will likely vote based on their favorite track (also, they have actual FANS who will be biased), compared to lesser know musicians who get voted only based on that one track.

      And that's even assuming that we'd get enough people to vote to even receive some kind of result. And it would be an ENORMOUS undertaking considering that there are 200+ artists.

      Thanks for trying to help out, but this idea really just doesn't work.

      Delete
  11. Holy hell, why so much butthurt over this? This is not a list of "THE BEST 1337 BRONY MUSICIANS OMGAWD", it's an organized list of brony musicians based on subscriber count. There seriously isn't anything wrong with that, so just build a bridge and get over it.

    Anyways, it looks like you missed EHT with 1,131 subs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Also: It looks like you're counting the subs from my old channel (xGiveMeUrLifex). I only have 1,117 on my new one (SonicBreakbeat). Thanks!

      Delete
  12. Replies
    1. I don't think he's made any brony music, so he's not on the list. If I missed him releasing any pony tracks, be sure to link them, though.

      Delete
    2. Rainbow Dash Likes Girls (Stay Gay Pony Girl!)
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vcjso2HmQqo

      GOT MY PONY SPAM FOR YOU
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRP1DUdU3d0

      Galactic Dancing doesn't seem to exist anymore, but that made EqD in early 2011

      Delete
    3. Ignore that last part; I'm an idiot. Galactic Dancing appears to be the name of his page EqD linked to. The track was Rainbow Dash Likes Girls

      Delete
  13. Replacer and Feather have more now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Most of the people on this list have more now. In fact, the list goes slightly out of date less than a day after it gets updated. However, I'm a pretty busy and can't update it every single time someone gets more subscribers. Hence the reason I added the "updated Feb 9th" at the end. I'll update the list around the time when Mic hits 50k.

      Delete
    2. The only exception is when I find out that someone is missing from the list, in which case I add them immediately.

      Delete
  14. Where is Megaphoric? She has over 2000 subs...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cntrl-F = find, she was sitting at #85 ;)

      Delete
  15. Cherax Destructor also hit 1k recently.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Eile and Feather have more now.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Updated the original thread rather than having a new one. New updated comments from December 2013 on will be here.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Just a note i hate having dead links and missing profile so I will try to have profiles added for Vinyl Scratch, Twitch, Ponyphonic, TuXe, Poni1Kenobi, Megaphoric, PhonyBrony, MelodicPony
    Lectro Dub, Muffoxx, Michael Pallante, VivaceCapriccioso, SMOR3S, BronyOff, UndreamedPanic, Yoka the Changeling, Undefined Variable, SerenaMidori, LilyCloudVA, MusicalPony/Colour District, ESPPony

    ReplyDelete
  19. Found 2 to add
    1,225 Glitchhog/Avenir (how did this happen? gah)
    1,181 PegaSix

    ReplyDelete
  20. Need to add Slendermane 2,040
    https://www.youtube.com/user/LeonTheRabbit1/about

    ReplyDelete
  21. SlyphStorm: 2437 Subs
    VocalScorePony: 1296 Subs

    ReplyDelete
  22. It looks like you missed 4EverfreeBrony, who has 1,785 subscribers: http://www.youtube.com/user/4everfreebrony

    It also looks like you guys missed Sonic Rainboom, it's a shame his music gets overlooked so often; he would be an Earth Pony with 245 subscribers: http://www.youtube.com/user/originalph00tbag
    (He really does make some good music, and I think he could use some more attention)

    That said, thanks for putting this list together, you guys!

    ReplyDelete
  23. How could you forget JackTHerbert? He has 39,583 subscribers! I know he uploads a lot of other stuff besides music and that's where most of his subs came from but you've got others on the list that do other things too. I think he's got more than enough songs to his name for him not to be counted on the list.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I guess we can add him as he does show SOME songs listed in aplylsit below, With nearly 40,000 subs that really does throw off the #'s as about almost all his traffic is due to other things then music. Again the main reason why people aren't on bmd these days is because they simply don't submit a profile themselves!

    ReplyDelete
  25. https://www.youtube.com/user/Melodosis/videos
    1450 subs

    ReplyDelete
  26. http://www.youtube.com/user/Korwuption/videos
    2,900 subs

    ReplyDelete
  27. all the people who were missing last time have been added today!

    ReplyDelete
  28. I broke 1,000 subscribers earlier this month. Just a heads up.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Are you guys updating this? :P

    ReplyDelete
  30. Once or twice a year....we may update this for the summer since we are at the half way mark.

    ReplyDelete
  31. That would be great. I'm looking forward for update :)

    ReplyDelete
  32. I dont see SimGretina

    ReplyDelete
  33. Ponytronic, Tif Whitney, Pandora Typography, Speedcore Dave, Faux Snyder, and FritzyBeat are all past 1K now

    ReplyDelete
  34. Jastrian https://www.youtube.com/user/jastrian

    ReplyDelete
  35. I think Derpydety / Kind Tide should be considered "inactive", as he didn't post any pony track for over a year xP

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He had a collab with AndTheRainfall this year that was pony inspired. On there on a technicality basically....

      Delete
  36. The most tragic thing about this list is that HeyLasFas's sub count of 940 is still too low for him to even be on it. If the creator of motherfucking DESTINY (not to mention NIGHTFALL), who's been doing this since 2010, can't even get onto this list, what purpose does it even serve other than to showcase that we as a community are not doing a good enough job of directing people to the really good music?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree completely. I'm stunned they are not on the list yet and there's a ton of musicians for no rhyme or reason aren't on here yet. What it does show is we as fellow musicians and brony music fans need to support the ACTIVE brony musicians making great music today.

      Delete
  37. "Someone made a list, we were all feeling bitter
    Till Tara Strong said to stop it on Twitter."

    ReplyDelete
  38. Will you compile a list of the "top brony songs of 2014" like you've done in previous years?

    ReplyDelete
  39. Can you add Wubcake?

    ReplyDelete
  40. Wait,what about Ponytronic, Tif Whitney, Pandora Typography, Speedcore Dave, Faux Snyder,FritzyBeat,etc.

    ReplyDelete
  41. out of those we missed ponytronic, pandora is a visual artist not a musical one, and we got the rest on there.

    ReplyDelete